No Function with
Problem
Prove that there is no function satisfying
Field
Putnam / Combinatorics / Number Theory
Why It's Beautiful
The problem looks like it's about functions and iteration — but the real obstruction is purely combinatorial: a fixed-point-free involution on a finite set requires the set to have even size. The number 2025 is odd, and that's the entire reason no such can exist.
The proof has a satisfying three-act structure:
- Show induces a well-defined map on .
- Show that map is a fixed-point-free involution.
- Derive a contradiction from the odd size of .
The same argument kills for any odd .
Key Idea / Trick
Derive the periodicity , which lets descend to a map on . Then show (involution) and has no fixed points. A fixed-point-free involution pairs elements into 2-element orbits, requiring an even-sized set — but is odd.
Difficulty
3 / 5
Tags
Putnam, Functions, Involution, Modular arithmetic, Parity, Fixed points, Combinatorics
No Function with — Answer
Let for convenience. Suppose for contradiction that satisfies for all .
Step 1: Periodicity —
Apply to both sides of :
But also, applying the functional equation to in place of :
Combining: for all .
Step 2: descends to a map on
Since , the residue depends only on . So define:
This is well-defined. From , we get:
So is an involution (), hence a bijection.
Step 3: has no fixed points
Suppose for some , i.e., for some with .
Then for some integer . Applying again using Step 1:
But , so , giving — not an integer. Contradiction.
So is a fixed-point-free involution on .
Step 4: Contradiction
A fixed-point-free involution partitions every element into a 2-element orbit (since and ). So the orbits partition into pairs, requiring to be even.
But is odd. Contradiction.
Why 2025 specifically?
The proof works for any odd . For even , no contradiction arises — and indeed has a solution: .
The key is not any special property of 2025 beyond its being odd.