🧮 Brain Teaser

The Circle Has Only One Entire Parametrization

Find all pairs of entire functions f,g:C→Cf, g : \mathbb{C} \to \mathbb{C} such that

f(z)2+g(z)2=1for all z∈C.f(z)^2 + g(z)^2 = 1 \qquad \text{for all } z \in \mathbb{C}.

The pair f=cos⁡zf = \cos z, g=sin⁡zg = \sin z is one solution, and so is f=cos⁡(z3+ez)f=\cos(z^3+e^z), g=sin⁡(z3+ez)g=\sin(z^3+e^z). Are there any others? For example, is there a solution that is not of the form (cos⁡h,sin⁡h)(\cos h, \sin h), or one built from entirely different functions?

Follow-up (optional): What happens for fn+gn=1f^n + g^n = 1 with n≥3n \ge 3?

entire functionsholomorphic logarithmfunctional equationPicard theoremFermat curveuniversal cover

Answer: The Circle Has Only One Entire Parametrization

Key Idea / Intuition

Over C\mathbb{C}, the circle x2+y2=1x^2+y^2=1 is secretly a hyperbola. With u=x+iyu = x+iy and v=x−iyv = x-iy the equation becomes uv=1uv = 1, and this curve is just a copy of C∗=C∖{0}\mathbb{C}^* = \mathbb{C}\setminus\{0\}. So a solution (f,g)(f,g) is the same thing as an entire function u=f+igu = f+ig that never vanishes. Every nonvanishing entire function is e(entire)e^{(\text{entire})}, because exp⁡:C→C∗\exp:\mathbb{C}\to\mathbb{C}^* is the universal cover and C\mathbb{C} is simply connected. Unwinding u=eihu = e^{ih} forces f=cos⁡hf=\cos h and g=sin⁡hg = \sin h.


Formal Proof / Solution

Answer. The solutions are exactly

f=cos⁡h,g=sin⁡h,h an arbitrary entire function.f = \cos h, \qquad g = \sin h, \qquad h \text{ an arbitrary entire function}.

The function hh is unique up to adding a constant 2πk2\pi k, k∈Zk\in\mathbb{Z}.

Step 1: Factor. Since f2+g2=(f+ig)(f−ig)f^2+g^2 = (f+ig)(f-ig), the equation reads

(f+ig)(f−ig)=1.(f+ig)(f-ig) = 1 .

Set u=f+igu = f+ig and v=f−igv = f-ig. Both are entire, and uv≡1uv \equiv 1. Hence uu has no zeros and v=1/uv = 1/u.

Step 2: Take a logarithm. uu is entire and nowhere zero, so u′/uu'/u is entire. Since C\mathbb{C} is simply connected, u′/uu'/u has an entire primitive LL. Then

(ue−L)′=(u′−uL′)e−L=0.\left(u e^{-L}\right)' = (u' - u L') e^{-L} = 0 .

So u=c eLu = c\,e^{L} with c≠0c \neq 0. Absorbing cc into LL gives u=eL~u = e^{\tilde L} for an entire L~\tilde L. Write L~=ih\tilde L = i h, which defines the entire function h=−iL~h = -i\tilde L. Then

f+ig=eih,f−ig=e−ih.f + i g = e^{ih}, \qquad f - i g = e^{-ih}.

Step 3: Solve the linear system. Adding and subtracting the two equations gives

f=eih+e−ih2=cos⁡h,g=eih−e−ih2i=sin⁡h.f = \frac{e^{ih}+e^{-ih}}{2} = \cos h, \qquad g = \frac{e^{ih}-e^{-ih}}{2i} = \sin h .

Step 4: Converse and uniqueness. For any entire hh, the identity cos⁡2h+sin⁡2h=1\cos^2 h + \sin^2 h = 1 holds pointwise, so every such pair is a solution. Now suppose eih1=eih2e^{ih_1} = e^{ih_2}. Then h1−h2h_1 - h_2 is a continuous function taking values in the discrete set 2πZ2\pi\mathbb{Z}. Since C\mathbb{C} is connected, it is constant. ■\blacksquare

So there are no exotic solutions. Every entire map of C\mathbb{C} into the complex circle factors through the "angle" map h↦(cos⁡h,sin⁡h)h \mapsto (\cos h, \sin h).


Follow-up: fn+gn=1f^n + g^n = 1 for n≥3n \ge 3

For n≥3n\ge 3 the only entire solutions are constants.

Suppose fn+gn=1f^n+g^n=1 and g≢0g\not\equiv 0. Let φ=f/g\varphi = f/g, which is meromorphic on C\mathbb{C}. The equation becomes

gn(φn+1)=1.g^n(\varphi^n + 1) = 1 .

Consider the values ζ\zeta with ζn=−1\zeta^n = -1:

  • Where g≠0g \neq 0, we cannot have φn=−1\varphi^n = -1, since then the left side would be 00.
  • Where g=0g = 0, we have fn=1f^n = 1, so f≠0f \neq 0 and φ=∞\varphi = \infty.

So φ\varphi omits all nn roots of ζn=−1\zeta^n=-1. By Picard's theorem for meromorphic functions, a meromorphic function on C\mathbb{C} omitting 33 values is constant. For n≥3n\ge3 this gives φ≡c\varphi \equiv c. Then gn(cn+1)=1g^n(c^n+1)=1, so gg is constant, and therefore ff is constant too.

For n=2n=2, φ\varphi omits only the two values ±i\pm i, so Picard gives no obstruction. Indeed φ=cot⁡h\varphi = \cot h in that case.

Geometrically, the Fermat curve xn+yn=1x^n+y^n=1 has genus (n−1)(n−2)/2(n-1)(n-2)/2. For n=2n=2 this is genus 00, a punctured sphere ≅C∗\cong \mathbb{C}^*, which is covered by C\mathbb{C}. For n≥3n \ge 3 the curve is hyperbolic, and Picard-type theorems forbid nonconstant entire curves in it.

Source: Mathematical folklore (Fermat functional equation for entire functions; cf. F. Gross, 1966)

Type: Complex AnalysisSource: Mathematical folklore (Fermat functional equation for entire functions; cf. F. Gross, 1966)Edit on GitHub ↗