The Circle Has Only One Entire Parametrization
Find all pairs of entire functions such that
The pair , is one solution, and so is , . Are there any others? For example, is there a solution that is not of the form , or one built from entirely different functions?
Follow-up (optional): What happens for with ?
Answer: The Circle Has Only One Entire Parametrization
Key Idea / Intuition
Over , the circle is secretly a hyperbola. With and the equation becomes , and this curve is just a copy of . So a solution is the same thing as an entire function that never vanishes. Every nonvanishing entire function is , because is the universal cover and is simply connected. Unwinding forces and .
Formal Proof / Solution
Answer. The solutions are exactly
The function is unique up to adding a constant , .
Step 1: Factor. Since , the equation reads
Set and . Both are entire, and . Hence has no zeros and .
Step 2: Take a logarithm. is entire and nowhere zero, so is entire. Since is simply connected, has an entire primitive . Then
So with . Absorbing into gives for an entire . Write , which defines the entire function . Then
Step 3: Solve the linear system. Adding and subtracting the two equations gives
Step 4: Converse and uniqueness. For any entire , the identity holds pointwise, so every such pair is a solution. Now suppose . Then is a continuous function taking values in the discrete set . Since is connected, it is constant.
So there are no exotic solutions. Every entire map of into the complex circle factors through the "angle" map .
Follow-up: for
For the only entire solutions are constants.
Suppose and . Let , which is meromorphic on . The equation becomes
Consider the values with :
- Where , we cannot have , since then the left side would be .
- Where , we have , so and .
So omits all roots of . By Picard's theorem for meromorphic functions, a meromorphic function on omitting values is constant. For this gives . Then , so is constant, and therefore is constant too.
For , omits only the two values , so Picard gives no obstruction. Indeed in that case.
Geometrically, the Fermat curve has genus . For this is genus , a punctured sphere , which is covered by . For the curve is hyperbolic, and Picard-type theorems forbid nonconstant entire curves in it.
Source: Mathematical folklore (Fermat functional equation for entire functions; cf. F. Gross, 1966)