Answer: Two Integrals, One Curve
Key Idea / Intuition
Each of the two terms in (a) looks impossible to integrate in elementary terms. But both describe the same curve x7+y3=1 in the unit square. One integral measures the area under it with vertical strips, and the other measures the same area with horizontal strips. So the two integrals are equal and I=0.
Part (b) uses the same idea: the graph of fโ1 is the graph of f reflected across y=x. The area under fโ1 is a rectangle minus the area under f, and f is easy to integrate.
Formal Proof / Solution
Part (a)
Step 1: The two integrands are inverse functions. Let g(x)=(1โx7)1/3 on [0,1]. For x,yโ[0,1],
y=(1โx7)1/3โบy3=1โx7โบx7=1โy3โบx=(1โy3)1/7.
So gโ1(y)=(1โy3)1/7, which is exactly the second integrand. Both are decreasing bijections of [0,1] with 0โฆ1 and 1โฆ0.
Step 2: Count one region in two ways. Define
R={(x,y)โ[0,1]2:x7+y3โค1}.
Integrate the indicator 1Rโ over [0,1]2, which is legitimate by Tonelli since it is nonnegative and measurable.
- Vertical slices: for fixed x, the condition is 0โคyโค(1โx7)1/3, so
Area(R)=โซ01โ(1โx7)1/3dx.
- Horizontal slices: for fixed y, the condition is 0โคxโค(1โy3)1/7, so
Area(R)=โซ01โ(1โy3)1/7dy.
Step 3: Conclude. The two integrals are equal, hence
I=0โ.
Generalization. The same argument gives, for all p,q>0,
โซ01โ(1โxp)1/qdx=โซ01โ(1โxq)1/pdx.
Remark (Beta function check). Substituting t=x7 gives
โซ01โ(1โx7)1/3dx=71โB(71โ,34โ)=ฮ(31/21)ฮ(8/7)ฮ(4/3)โ.
This expression is symmetric in 3โ7, which confirms the result. The geometric argument needs none of this machinery.
Part (b)
Step 1: Locate the endpoints. We have f(0)=0 and f(1)=2, so fโ1 maps [0,2] onto [0,1].
Step 2: Substitute y=f(x). Then dy=fโฒ(x)dx, and y:0โ2 corresponds to x:0โ1. This gives
J=โซ01โxfโฒ(x)dx.
Step 3: Integrate by parts.
J=[xf(x)]01โโโซ01โf(x)dx=1โ
2โโซ01โ(x5+x)dx=2โ(61โ+21โ).
Therefore
J=34โโ.
Geometric reading. In general,
โซabโf+โซf(a)f(b)โfโ1=bf(b)โaf(a).
The area under f on [0,1] and the area under fโ1 on [0,2] together tile the 1ร2 rectangle. Part (a) is the special case where the curve is its own reflection, so the two pieces must have equal area.