๐Ÿงฎ Brain Teaser

Two Integrals, One Curve

(a) Evaluate I=โˆซ01(1โˆ’x73โ€…โ€Šโˆ’โ€…โ€Š1โˆ’x37)โ€‰dx.I=\int_0^1 \left( \sqrt[3]{1-x^7}\;-\;\sqrt[7]{1-x^3}\right)\,dx .

(b) Let f(x)=x5+xf(x)=x^5+x. This is a strictly increasing bijection Rโ†’R\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R}, but fโˆ’1f^{-1} has no elementary closed form. Evaluate J=โˆซ02fโˆ’1(y)โ€‰dy.J=\int_0^2 f^{-1}(y)\,dy .

(Try to avoid Beta/Gamma functions in (a) and avoid solving a quintic in (b).)

inverse functionarea countingFubiniintegration beesymmetry

Answer: Two Integrals, One Curve

Key Idea / Intuition

Each of the two terms in (a) looks impossible to integrate in elementary terms. But both describe the same curve x7+y3=1x^7+y^3=1 in the unit square. One integral measures the area under it with vertical strips, and the other measures the same area with horizontal strips. So the two integrals are equal and I=0I=0.

Part (b) uses the same idea: the graph of fโˆ’1f^{-1} is the graph of ff reflected across y=xy=x. The area under fโˆ’1f^{-1} is a rectangle minus the area under ff, and ff is easy to integrate.


Formal Proof / Solution

Part (a)

Step 1: The two integrands are inverse functions. Let g(x)=(1โˆ’x7)1/3g(x)=(1-x^7)^{1/3} on [0,1][0,1]. For x,yโˆˆ[0,1]x,y\in[0,1], y=(1โˆ’x7)1/3โ€…โ€ŠโŸบโ€…โ€Šy3=1โˆ’x7โ€…โ€ŠโŸบโ€…โ€Šx7=1โˆ’y3โ€…โ€ŠโŸบโ€…โ€Šx=(1โˆ’y3)1/7.y=(1-x^7)^{1/3}\iff y^3=1-x^7 \iff x^7=1-y^3 \iff x=(1-y^3)^{1/7}. So gโˆ’1(y)=(1โˆ’y3)1/7g^{-1}(y)=(1-y^3)^{1/7}, which is exactly the second integrand. Both are decreasing bijections of [0,1][0,1] with 0โ†ฆ10\mapsto 1 and 1โ†ฆ01\mapsto 0.

Step 2: Count one region in two ways. Define R={(x,y)โˆˆ[0,1]2:x7+y3โ‰ค1}.R=\{(x,y)\in[0,1]^2 : x^7+y^3\le 1\}. Integrate the indicator 1R\mathbf 1_R over [0,1]2[0,1]^2, which is legitimate by Tonelli since it is nonnegative and measurable.

  • Vertical slices: for fixed xx, the condition is 0โ‰คyโ‰ค(1โˆ’x7)1/30\le y\le (1-x^7)^{1/3}, so Areaโก(R)=โˆซ01(1โˆ’x7)1/3โ€‰dx.\operatorname{Area}(R)=\int_0^1 (1-x^7)^{1/3}\,dx.
  • Horizontal slices: for fixed yy, the condition is 0โ‰คxโ‰ค(1โˆ’y3)1/70\le x\le (1-y^3)^{1/7}, so Areaโก(R)=โˆซ01(1โˆ’y3)1/7โ€‰dy.\operatorname{Area}(R)=\int_0^1 (1-y^3)^{1/7}\,dy.

Step 3: Conclude. The two integrals are equal, hence I=0.\boxed{I=0}.

Generalization. The same argument gives, for all p,q>0p,q>0, โˆซ01(1โˆ’xp)1/qโ€‰dx=โˆซ01(1โˆ’xq)1/pโ€‰dx.\int_0^1 (1-x^p)^{1/q}\,dx=\int_0^1 (1-x^q)^{1/p}\,dx.

Remark (Beta function check). Substituting t=x7t=x^7 gives โˆซ01(1โˆ’x7)1/3dx=17Bโ€‰โฃ(17,43)=ฮ“(8/7)โ€‰ฮ“(4/3)ฮ“(31/21).\int_0^1 (1-x^7)^{1/3}dx=\tfrac17 B\!\left(\tfrac17,\tfrac43\right)=\frac{\Gamma(8/7)\,\Gamma(4/3)}{\Gamma(31/21)}. This expression is symmetric in 3โ†”73\leftrightarrow 7, which confirms the result. The geometric argument needs none of this machinery.

Part (b)

Step 1: Locate the endpoints. We have f(0)=0f(0)=0 and f(1)=2f(1)=2, so fโˆ’1f^{-1} maps [0,2][0,2] onto [0,1][0,1].

Step 2: Substitute y=f(x)y=f(x). Then dy=fโ€ฒ(x)โ€‰dxdy=f'(x)\,dx, and y:0โ†’2y:0\to 2 corresponds to x:0โ†’1x:0\to1. This gives J=โˆซ01xโ€‰fโ€ฒ(x)โ€‰dx.J=\int_0^1 x\,f'(x)\,dx.

Step 3: Integrate by parts. J=[xf(x)]01โˆ’โˆซ01f(x)โ€‰dx=1โ‹…2โˆ’โˆซ01(x5+x)โ€‰dx=2โˆ’(16+12).J=\big[x f(x)\big]_0^1-\int_0^1 f(x)\,dx = 1\cdot 2-\int_0^1 (x^5+x)\,dx = 2-\left(\tfrac16+\tfrac12\right). Therefore J=43.\boxed{J=\tfrac43}.

Geometric reading. In general, โˆซabf+โˆซf(a)f(b)fโˆ’1=bโ€‰f(b)โˆ’aโ€‰f(a).\int_a^b f+\int_{f(a)}^{f(b)} f^{-1} = b\,f(b)-a\,f(a). The area under ff on [0,1][0,1] and the area under fโˆ’1f^{-1} on [0,2][0,2] together tile the 1ร—21\times 2 rectangle. Part (a) is the special case where the curve is its own reflection, so the two pieces must have equal area.

Source: Integration bee folklore (classic inverse-function integral)

Type: IntegrationSource: Integration bee folklore (classic inverse-function integral)Edit on GitHub โ†—