๐Ÿงฎ Brain Teaser

The Covering Space That Wraps Around Twice

Let p:S1โ†’S1p: S^1 \to S^1 be the map p(z)=z2p(z) = z^2 (viewing S1โŠ‚CS^1 \subset \mathbb{C}).

(a) Show directly that pp is a covering map, and identify the number of sheets.

(b) The induced homomorphism pโˆ—:ฯ€1(S1,1)โ†’ฯ€1(S1,1)p_*: \pi_1(S^1, 1) \to \pi_1(S^1, 1) is a map Zโ†’Z\mathbb{Z} \to \mathbb{Z}. What is it explicitly?

(c) Now consider the induced map on fundamental groups for the nn-sheeted cover pn(z)=znp_n(z) = z^n. Without further calculation, what does this tell you about which subgroups of Z\mathbb{Z} arise as images of covering-induced maps ฯ€1(S1)โ†’ฯ€1(S1)\pi_1(S^1) \to \pi_1(S^1)?

covering spacesfundamental groupcircleinduced homomorphismsubgroups of Z

Answer: The Covering Space That Wraps Around Twice

Key Idea / Intuition

The map zโ†ฆz2z \mapsto z^2 wraps the circle around itself twice โ€” every point has exactly two preimages, and small arcs upstairs map homeomorphically to arcs downstairs. The fundamental group of S1S^1 is Z\mathbb{Z}, generated by the loop that goes around once. Upstairs, going around once only covers half the circle downstairs, so the induced map on ฯ€1\pi_1 must be multiplication by 22. The general pattern reveals that every nontrivial subgroup of Z\mathbb{Z} (all of which are of the form nZn\mathbb{Z}) appears as the image of such a covering map.


Formal Proof / Solution

Part (a): p(z)=z2p(z) = z^2 is a 2-sheeted covering map

We need to show every point of S1S^1 has an evenly covered neighborhood.

Given any wโˆˆS1w \in S^1, let UU be an open arc in S1S^1 not containing โˆ’w-w (the antipodal point). Then: pโˆ’1(U)=V1โŠ”V2p^{-1}(U) = V_1 \sqcup V_2 where V1V_1 and V2V_2 are the two open arcs of S1S^1 mapping to UU โ€” specifically the two square roots of points in UU. These arcs are disjoint (since โˆ’wโˆ‰U-w \notin U means the two arcs don't overlap), and pโˆฃVi:Viโ†’Up\big|_{V_i}: V_i \to U is a homeomorphism for each ii.

Thus pp is a covering map with 2 sheets (each fiber pโˆ’1(w)p^{-1}(w) has exactly 2 points: {w1/2,โˆ’w1/2}\{w^{1/2}, -w^{1/2}\}).


Part (b): The induced map pโˆ—:Zโ†’Zp_*: \mathbb{Z} \to \mathbb{Z}

Recall ฯ€1(S1,1)โ‰…Z\pi_1(S^1, 1) \cong \mathbb{Z}, generated by the loop ฮณ:[0,1]โ†’S1,ฮณ(t)=e2ฯ€it,\gamma: [0,1] \to S^1, \quad \gamma(t) = e^{2\pi i t}, which winds around once (representing 1โˆˆZ1 \in \mathbb{Z}).

The induced map sends [ฮณ]โ†ฆ[pโˆ˜ฮณ][\gamma] \mapsto [p \circ \gamma], and: (pโˆ˜ฮณ)(t)=ฮณ(t)2=e4ฯ€it.(p \circ \gamma)(t) = \gamma(t)^2 = e^{4\pi i t}.

This loop winds around S1S^1 twice, so [pโˆ˜ฮณ]=2โˆˆZ[p \circ \gamma] = 2 \in \mathbb{Z}.

Therefore: pโˆ—:Zโ†’Z,pโˆ—(n)=2n.\boxed{p_*: \mathbb{Z} \to \mathbb{Z}, \quad p_*(n) = 2n.}

That is, pโˆ—p_* is multiplication by 22.


Part (c): All subgroups of Z\mathbb{Z} via covering maps

For the nn-sheeted cover pn(z)=znp_n(z) = z^n, the same argument gives: (pnโˆ˜ฮณ)(t)=e2ฯ€int,(p_n \circ \gamma)(t) = e^{2\pi i n t}, which winds around nn times, so (pn)โˆ—:Zโ†’Z(p_n)_*: \mathbb{Z} \to \mathbb{Z} is multiplication by nn.

The image of (pn)โˆ—(p_n)_* is the subgroup nZโ‰คZn\mathbb{Z} \leq \mathbb{Z}.

Now recall the classification theorem: the subgroups of Z\mathbb{Z} are exactly {0}={0}\{0\} = \{0\} and nZn\mathbb{Z} for nโ‰ฅ1n \geq 1. These are in bijection with the covering spaces of S1S^1:

| Cover | Map | (pn)โˆ—(p_n)_* image | Subgroup | |---|---|---|---| | S1โ†’znS1S^1 \xrightarrow{z^n} S^1 | nn-sheeted | multiplication by nn | nZn\mathbb{Z} | | Rโ†’S1\mathbb{R} \to S^1 (universal) | โˆž\infty-sheeted | trivial | {0}\{0\} |

Conclusion: Every subgroup of Z\mathbb{Z} arises as the image of the induced map on ฯ€1\pi_1 from some covering map S1โ†’S1S^1 \to S^1. This is a perfect illustration of the correspondence between subgroups of ฯ€1(B)\pi_1(B) and covering spaces of BB: the image pโˆ—(ฯ€1(E))p_*(\pi_1(E)) inside ฯ€1(B)\pi_1(B) completely characterizes the covering up to equivalence.


Bonus elegance: The trivial subgroup {0}\{0\} corresponds to the universal cover Rโ†’S1\mathbb{R} \to S^1, tโ†ฆe2ฯ€itt \mapsto e^{2\pi i t}, where ฯ€1(R)=0\pi_1(\mathbb{R}) = 0. The whole group Z\mathbb{Z} (the identity cover) corresponds to zโ†ฆzz \mapsto z, a 1-sheeted cover.

Source: Munkres, Topology, Chapter 13 (Covering Spaces); also Hatcher Algebraic Topology ยง1.3

Type: topologySource: Munkres, Topology, Chapter 13 (Covering Spaces); also Hatcher Algebraic Topology ยง1.3Edit on GitHub โ†—