๐Ÿงฎ Brain Teaser

The Quotient of a Compact Space by a Closed Equivalence Relation

Let X=[0,1]X = [0, 1] and define an equivalence relation โˆผ\sim on XX by identifying all points in the closed set {0,1}\{0, 1\} to a single point. Let X/โˆผX/{\sim} denote the quotient space.

Prove that X/โˆผX/{\sim} is homeomorphic to the circle S1S^1.

More precisely: describe explicitly a homeomorphism f:X/โˆผโ†’S1f: X/{\sim} \to S^1, and explain why the quotient map machinery guarantees it is indeed a homeomorphism โ€” not just a continuous bijection.

quotient topologycompact-to-Hausdorffhomeomorphismcircleidentification space

Answer: Quotient of Interval Gives Circle

Key Idea / Intuition

The interval [0,1][0,1] wraps around the circle if we glue its two endpoints together โ€” this is geometrically obvious. The analytic map tโ†ฆe2ฯ€itt \mapsto e^{2\pi i t} does exactly this gluing. The key topological insight is that a continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is automatically a homeomorphism โ€” so we don't need to construct the inverse explicitly; compactness does the work for us.


Formal Proof / Solution

Step 1: Define the candidate map.

Consider the map f:[0,1]โ†’S1f: [0,1] \to S^1 defined by

f(t)=e2ฯ€it.f(t) = e^{2\pi i t}.

This is continuous, and f(0)=f(1)=1โˆˆS1f(0) = f(1) = 1 \in S^1, so ff is constant on the equivalence class {0,1}\{0, 1\} and constant (trivially) on every singleton {t}\{t\} for tโˆˆ(0,1)t \in (0,1).

Step 2: Factor through the quotient.

Since ff is constant on each equivalence class of โˆผ\sim, the universal property of the quotient topology gives a unique continuous map

f~:X/โˆผโ€…โ€ŠโŸถโ€…โ€ŠS1\tilde{f}: X/{\sim} \;\longrightarrow\; S^1

such that f~โˆ˜q=f\tilde{f} \circ q = f, where q:Xโ†’X/โˆผq: X \to X/{\sim} is the quotient map.

Explicitly, f~([t])=e2ฯ€it\tilde{f}([t]) = e^{2\pi i t}.

Step 3: f~\tilde{f} is a bijection.

  • Surjective: Every point e2ฯ€itโˆˆS1e^{2\pi i t} \in S^1 is hit by some tโˆˆ[0,1]t \in [0,1].
  • Injective: If f~([s])=f~([t])\tilde{f}([s]) = \tilde{f}([t]), then e2ฯ€is=e2ฯ€ite^{2\pi i s} = e^{2\pi i t}, so sโˆ’tโˆˆZs - t \in \mathbb{Z}. Since s,tโˆˆ[0,1]s, t \in [0,1], this forces either s=ts = t or {s,t}={0,1}\{s,t\} = \{0,1\}. In either case [s]=[t][s] = [t] in X/โˆผX/{\sim}.

Step 4: Apply the compact-to-Hausdorff theorem.

  • X/โˆผX/{\sim} is compact: it is the continuous image of the compact space [0,1][0,1] under qq.
  • S1โŠ‚R2S^1 \subset \mathbb{R}^2 is Hausdorff.

Now use the following standard theorem:

Theorem. A continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space is a homeomorphism.

Proof sketch: Let CโІX/โˆผC \subseteq X/{\sim} be closed, hence compact. Its image f~(C)\tilde{f}(C) is compact, hence closed in the Hausdorff space S1S^1. So f~\tilde{f} sends closed sets to closed sets, i.e., (f~โˆ’1)(\tilde{f}^{-1}) is continuous. โ–ก\square

Conclusion.

f~:X/โˆผโ†’โ€…โ€Šโˆผโ€…โ€ŠS1\tilde{f}: X/{\sim} \xrightarrow{\;\sim\;} S^1 is a homeomorphism. Geometrically: collapsing the two endpoints of [0,1][0,1] to a single point is exactly the same as bending the interval into a circle and gluing the ends. โ– \blacksquare


Why does this matter?

The compact-to-Hausdorff trick is ubiquitous in topology. It saves you from ever having to verify continuity of an inverse directly โ€” compactness is doing the real work. The same argument shows, for instance, that [0,1]2/โˆ‚([0,1]2)โ‰…S2[0,1]^2 / \partial([0,1]^2) \cong S^2, or that R/Zโ‰…S1\mathbb{R}/\mathbb{Z} \cong S^1.

Source: Munkres, Topology, Chapter 3 (Quotient Topology); Lee, Introduction to Topological Manifolds, Chapter 3

Type: topologySource: Munkres, Topology, Chapter 3 (Quotient Topology); Lee, Introduction to Topological Manifolds, Chapter 3Edit on GitHub โ†—